A broken promise?
RFK Jr. said he would protect 9/11 responder; then administration struck with cuts to WTC program
By: Nancy Cutler
Rockland/Westchester Journal News
USA Today Network
..... Just before his confirmation as secretary of Health and Human Services, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. pledged to help 9/11 responders and survivors, two U. S. Senators from New York said Tuesday. [02/18/2025] But a day after he got the job, the Trump administration and Elon Musk's department of Government Efficiency hit the World Trade Center Health Program.
..... Democratic Senators Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillbrand are now demanding that Kennedy reverse "the rash and counterproductive terminations" and ensure ongoing health care for "those who answered the call on 9/11 and are now sick with respiratory ailments, cancer and other conditions."
...,. Up to 20% of staff at the WTC Health Program were affected by cuts of probationary workers and buyouts. HHS oversees the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which houses the WTC program.
..... The impact is exacerbated, elected officials and fired workers say by DOGE cuts to scientific research and last year's [2024] scrapping of permanent funding for the WTC program by Congress.
..... U.S. Representative Mike Lawler, whose district in New York;s Hudson Valley is home to many 9/11 responders, on Monday [02/17/2025] said he was talking with the Trump administration about the cuts.
..... "I am aware of the serious concerns pertaining to the WTC (Health Program) and have been working through the weekend [02/15-16/2025] with the White House to reverse the decision and ensure there are no impacts on providing care to our brave 9/11 heroes," said Lawler, a Republican whose 17th District includes Rockland and Putnam counties and parts of Westchester and Dutches. "There is nothing more important to me than fighting for our first responders, and I won't stop until this is rectified."
..... "These cuts are going to impact members care directly," said Anthony Gardner, a WTC program staff member who was notified via email on Saturday [02/15/2025] that he's lost his job. "For some of these members these delays are going to be life and death."
..... HHS and the CDC did not immediately respond to request for comment.
..... The union representing about 20,000 active and retired New York City firefighters cite statement by Musk and the Trump administration that if mistakes happen during the DOGE cuts, they'll correct them.
.....
"This is a mistake that needs to be corrected, and corrected quickly," Andrew Ansbro, president of the Uniformed Firefighters Association of Greater New York, told USA Today. "No one has ever accused the World Trade Center Heath Program of being run inefficiently, and no one has ever questioned the need for America to fund the helaht care program that helps the first responders, rescue workers and civilians."
..... Rupa Bhattacharyya, former special master of the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund, said WTC Health provides support for people in all 50 states. WTC Program cuts mean "that the heroes of 9/11 will face longer wait times, reduced services and delays in receiving tier compensation: through the VCF. which depends on certification from WTC Health Program doctors. "It is unconscionable."
.....
Bhattacharyya now serves on the boards of 9/11 Health Watch and Citizens for the extension of the Zadroga Act.
Fighting back on firing
..... Gardner found out he has been terminated form his job at the World Trade Center Health Program on the night of Saturday February 15. [2025] via a work email.
..... The elimination of his co-workers, including some who process claims and review treatments, will lead to delays, he said. there are currently 130,000 WTC program members being monitored, getting treatment, or both.
.....
Gardner has already submitted a rebuttal letter to his firing. But he wants more.
..... "No matte what happens, I'm really hoping that President Trump takes a closer look, especially to the cuts to these programs, how catastrophic they can be," he said. "I can't believe that's an intended consequence."
..... He noted that DOGE purports to fight fraud and abuse of federal funds. the WTC program is charged with preventing fraud and abuse by overseeing contracted providers and screening program applicants. "we make suer they meet criteria laid out by the Zadrog Act," he said.
..... Gardner has been with the WTC program for four years, originally as a contractor. About a year and a half ago, he was brought on as the public affairs specialist.
..... His experience was beyond the "probationary: level, only in this job but in paralytically his entire professional career. Gardner is a former senior vice president of government and community affairs for the 9/11 Memorial & Museum and the September 11th Victims Compensation Fund. He's volunteered with the 9/11 responder community.
..... "The mission is very important to me," Gardner said.
.....
It's also deeply personal.
..... Harvey Gardner, Anthony;s older brother by 10 years, was working for General Telecom on the 83rd floor in the north tower during the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.
..... Harvey Gardener and his IT General Telecom co-workers were above the impact zone of the first plane, They were trying to get to a stairwell, Harvey told their brother Mark in a phone call during the search.
..... "Harvey was trying to comfort his co-workers," Anthony Gardner recalled. "The courage that he showed, the compassion that he showed as he was facing the horror of the end of their lives together, has always inspired me."
A commitment through 2090
..... The World Trade Center Health Program provides health motoring and treatment for 9/11 related health conditions.
..... Responses, including police, firefighters, cleanup workers and others in rescue and recovery efforts around the World Trade Center site, can qualify few the helaht program. So can those who lived, worked or went to school in Lower Manhattan during and in the months after the terrorist attacks.
..... The program also supports people exposed at the Pentagon and Pennsylvania. the health program was established as part of the 2011 James Zadroga 9/11 Health and Compensation Act.
..... Dozens of health impacts have been found among those exposed to the toxic swirl around ground zero on and in the months after September 11, 2001.
..... Other DOGE cuts to research grant also jeopardize ongoing studies that could slow down additional health problems form being included in WTC program coverage.
..... "Any research hat comes out of World Trade Center Health care program can be applied to the long-term care of American firefighters," Ansbro said.
..... Getting Zadroga passed in 2011 took heavy lobbying images of first responders, weakened by 9/11 illness, walking the halls of Congress pushed lawmakers to act.
..... The WTC program is mandated through 2090. But funding shortages are perpetual.
..... The cuts pour on more insult for some who remember how Trump and Musk blew up the omnibus budget plan in December; [2024] the original deal fixed perpetual funding problems for the WTC program, but that was scrapped in the final deal.
..... the program faced consequences of careless MacIntosh even before that, said Benjamin Chevat, executive director at Tacitness for Extension of the James Zadrga Act.
..... In 2018, Trump's then-Office of Management and Budget Director Mick Mulvaney tried to terminate the National Institute of Occupations Safety and Health, Chevat said, "but did not seem to understand the extent the NIOSH was a critical part of the WTC Health Program.
..... "That proposal was stopped then," Chevat said, "and these cuts need to be reversed now."
USA Today's Eduardo Cuevas contributed to this report.