Paterson parents fear plan at School 28
Gifted program faces major reorganization
By: Joe Mallinconico
Paterson Press
PATERSON - Their acceptability's to Paterson's Gifted and Talented academy at School 28 was like winning the academic lottery - a ticket to the best high schools, great colleges and bright futures.
.....
Kids once ostracized for knowing all the answers in regular Paterson classes now thrived in an environment where everyone around them was smart, where no ones was bullied for studying too much, where being quirky or nearly was normal.
..... Their teachers had special training for gifted and talented programs. Their class sizes were smaller than those in other Paterson schools. Older students mentored the younger ones, instead of picking on them.
.....
The gifted and talented academy transformed Paterson's School 28 form being one of the lowest-performing in the state to being named the best in New Jersey in multiple years.
..... But the recent announcement that the gifted and talented academy would be split into two schools that also would contain general education classes has cast a cloud over School 28.
..... After the news broke, Paterson Press interviewed a dozen parents of students in the gifted academy who said they were baffled and bewildered by the decision.
..... They expressed fear and frustration over how the changes would affect their children.
..... A few said they continued living in Paterson only because School 28 was such a wonderful place, and now they are starting to look for houses in other municipalities.
..... "I don't understand why they would break something up that's been working so well for years," said Jessica Gonzalez, whose son is in the third grade at School 28, where she said he and his classmates speak "their own gifted and talented language," explaining the bond among the students.
..... Erika DeLeon, whose son is fourth grader in the gifted program, said the decision to split the school never came with any data or analysis of its impact on the program's success.
..... "Since when did putting education last become acceptable?" DeLeon asked.
..... The impending changes at School 28 scheduled take effect in September 2027 - result from superintendent Laurie Newell's effort to convert Paterson to a district with about eight regional middle schools.
.....
The first changes took effect in September 2025 in south Paterson, and the second phase will mostly affect schools in the 4th Ward in three months.
..... Newell praised School 28 in November 2024 when it was named both top elementary school and top middle school in New Jersey in U.S. News & World Report rankings, which are largely based on student test scores.
..... "I am incredibly proud of the School 28 community," the superintendent said at the time. "The dedication of the staff and the hard work of the students have created a learning environment that truly exemplifies excellence.
....."This recognition highlights the progress we are making as a district to ensure that every child in Paterson receives the education they need to succeed in the future," she said.
.....
Paterson Press asked the district's spokesperson, Aida Rosario, whether Newell was concerned the changes she was making would prevent School 28 from winning such honors.
..... "Rankings are determined independently by outside organizations, and the distinct does not speculate on future rankings," Rosario said. "The district's planning decisions are focused on providing high-quality educational opportunities for all students and supporting there continued success."
..... Newell has said her plan will improvisational equity in Paterson. But she hasn't said exactly how that will happen.
..... Under Newell's plan, two other Paterson schools would become gifted and talented "hubs" starting in 2027-2028: School 12 and Maria Magda O'Keef School. But the district has not provided a pubic explanation of what that "hub" status would entail.
From School 28 to Harvard, MIT
..... Evangeline Aranbar's oldest son graduated from the gifted program at School 28 six years ago. Now she said, he has finished his second year at Massachusetts Institute of Technology. His classmate and friend from School 28 attends Harvard, she said.
..... "I credit that to a large degree to gifted and talented," Aranbar said. "they bonded with each other. They motivated each other. They were form the same mindset."
..... She acknowledged that some people resent the gifted program.
.....
"This is Paterson. It's not the suburbs," she said. "You should take any chance you can to do better for your children. Why not?"
'Nobody wants this'
..... Under Newell's plan, gifted and talented classes for children below sixth grade would stay at School 28, while gifted students in middle school grades would attend School 4.
..... man of the School 28 parents interviewed for this story expressed concerns about whether their children's teachers would still have gifted and talented credentials, whether class sizes would rise, and whether after-school clubs would continue at both buildings.
..... "No one wants this," said Shaheda Zuma, whose child is in the fifth grade at the gifted academy. "Everyone is complaining. My son doesn't want to go to the other school. I'm very worried. I doesn't know what to do."
..... School 4 and School 28 sit on diagonal ends of the same block in Paterson's 1st Ward. They also sit between the turfs of two Paterson feuding drug gangs: 100k from North Main Street and the Blockboyz from the Riverview Towers apartment buildings.
..... The neighborhood is tough, dangerous and poor.
..... Several gifted and talented parents said they didn't think school 4 would be safe for their studious children. The classes may contain only gifted students - but, they asked, what about the lunchroom, the playground and the hallways?
..... Achoo 28 had just one bullying incident in 2024-2025, said its sate performance report. In contrast, School 4 had 25 bullying incidents, plus nine cases of violence, five instances of students having illegal substances, one case of a student with a weapon, and one instance of vandalism.
..... School 4 had 8.2 incidents pr 100 studiedness in 2024-2025, compared with 3.3 incidents for the entire Paterson district, the state report say.
..... Many parents interviewed said they likely would not send their children to School 4 if the changes take effect. Instead, they said, they would apply to charter schools or private schools or move elsewhere.
..... "My husband already started looking for a house in another district," said one parent.