6 events in Passaic County with a date

Petition before Supreme Court no threat to Obergefell

By: dace Potas
USA Today

..... A former county clerk in Kentucky has officially filed a petition to the Supreme Court, asking to overturn Obergefell v. Hodges, the ruling that found a constitutional right to same-sex marriage.
..... People should temper their reactions to this petition. There is no guarantee that this case will be heard, and there is no indication that the nation's highest court is likely to overturn the previous ruling.
..... The general public has a poor understanding of how the Supreme Court, and the judicial branch in general, actually works. The court is not a partisan machine hat takes cases based on the whims of the Republican Party, but rather a process-oriented institution that is very restrained.
..... While I understand the fears that members of the LGBTQ+ community hold at the prospect of losing their right to marry, fear-mongering coverage only stokes overreactions.
..... This case is not likely to be heard by the court, nor is it anywhere close to ending the constitutional protections for gay marriage.
..... The Supreme Court has discretion over what cases it takes, so a petition for review does not necessary mean that the panel will consider the issue. It takes the votes of four justices to eventually grant review in a case, which advances it to the court's docket.
..... All of this is to say that just because a petition is filed with the Supreme Court, that doesn't mean it will eventually be heard.
..... The vast majority are never heard. Of the more than 7,000 cases field each year, the Supreme Court grants review in only 100 to 150 of them.
..... In 2024, for example, the court ultimately ruled on just 59 cases.
..... While legislation is by no means a complete replacement for a constitutional amendment, the constitutional right to gay marriage is rendered somewhat obsolete by the Respect for Marriage Act, the 2022 piece of bipartisan legislation that requires states to recognize same-sex marriages performed in other states.
..... The odds of that legislation being overturned are extremely low, given gay marriage;s popularity, even among conservatives.

The fearmongering began almost immediately

..... But none of that stopped people from panicking at the prospect of the court considering such a case.
..... Obviously, the partisan hacks of X immediately latched onto this story to fearmonger, but even larger news sources like ABC couldn't help themselves form dedicating feature-length articles to the topic.
..... "Ten years after the Supreme Court extended marriage rights to same-sex couples nationwide, the justices this fall [2025] will consider for the first time whether to take up a case that explicitly asks them to overturn that decision," ABC News said in an X post.
..... Despite acknowledging the fact that the case is a "long shot" in its own article on the matter, ABC News chose to frame this piece in this manner because it sensationalizes the potential for Obergefell to be overturned, with little indication hat this is not an impending event.
..... Other news sources were far more honest in their framing, but ABC News' post is irresponsible because it capitalizes on a massive problem in American civic education. Others, including USA Today, have tied it to President Donald Trump's position, while highlighting that the case is unlikely to succeed.

Supreme Court literacy is important, but currently lacking

..... At the moment, same-sex marriage is extremely safe going into the future. So, what is all the worry about?
..... As it stands, very few Americans understand the judicial process that lead to a case being considered by the Supreme Court. Even many who are otherwise rather politically intelligent understand very little about how the Supreme Court operates.
.....The typical American comically knows little about the Supreme Court, from basic facts kike the number of justices to the branch of government within which the court is housed. Americans who have a limited understanding of this information naturally have little business understanding the meaning of a petition for certiorari or how precedent is overturned.
..... Partisan sources are aware of this and capitalize on it. democratic groups have already begun to incorporate the mere fact that someone has petitioned the court to review such a decision.
..... I've written previously about how people's views of the court are fr too simplistic, and that is an interconnected problem with this one. People do not understand the dynamic of the court well enough to actually make judgments beyond the partisan talking points.
..... Sources like the ABC News article may not be malicious, but their potential for harm is still great. America has a problem with civilization when it comes to the Supreme Court, but an honest news media has a responsibility to be conscious of framing court stories in relation to the public's knowledge.

..... Dace Potas is an opinion columnist for USA Today and a graduate of DePaul University with a degree in political science.

HOME