US judge orders DOGE, Musk to produce records
Reuters
..... A federal judge has ordered Elon Musk and his Department of Government Efficiency to turn over a variety of records and answer question describing their effort to slash federal spending.
.....
Wednesday [03/12/2025] night's decision by U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan in Washington, D.C., came in a lawsuit by 14 Democratic state attorneys general against DOGE and Musk and Republican President Donald Trump.
..... The states argued that Musk violated the Constitution by wielding power that only officials confirmed by the U.S. Senate can exercise under the appointment of Clause, and sought materials from him thorough a process known as discovery.
..... Chutkan, an appointee of former President Barack Obama, said her order focused mainly on who at DOGE was ,making cost-cutting decisions and how far they could go.
..... "Defendants argue that the "inner workings of government are immaterial to an Appointment Clause claim," she wrote.
..... "The court is not convinced, but that is a legal issue appropriate for resolution after fulsome briefing.
..... "At this stage," she added, "it is sufficient that plaintiffs; discovery requests intend to reveal the scope of DOGE's and Musk's authority."
..... The Department of Justice, which represents the defendants did not immediately respond on Thursday [03/13/2025] to a request for comment.
..... Chutkan limited discovery requests to material concerning magnetics, employees, contracts, grants, federal funding, legal agreements, databases and data management systems that involve or engage with the 14 states as well as entities they operate or fund.
..... She rejected the states' request to obtain sworn testimony through depositions, and said her order does not apply to Trump.
..... Republican and Democratic administration have long resisted efforts to force top White House advisers to provide court testimony or information they consider privileged.
..... Musk and DOGE have until April 2 [2025] to comply with Chutkan's order.
..... The lawsuit sought to bar DOGE from accessing information systems at several government departments and firing federal employees or putting them on leave.